Watch the full episode here:
Good evening. It's Thursday, October 26.
Tonight: every day that we get further away from the October 7 attack on Israel by Hamas, we have more and more American politicians demanding new and formal censorship programs against critics of Israel. One of the most destructive mistakes we made after 9/11 was that we allowed political leaders to convince us that we had to relinquish longstanding political rights in order to be safe. It was that tradeoff that led to authoritarian infringements like the Patriot Act and mass warrantless NSA domestic spying. As we have seen over and over throughout history, once you put a population into sufficient levels of fear, whether of a domestic enemy or a foreign threat, then they will not only be willing, but eager to give up core liberties in exchange for promises to be kept safe from that threat. This is exactly what numerous American politicians are doing now, led by Republican presidential candidates who are desperate to find a way to save their flailing campaigns – people like Nikki Haley, Ron DeSantis and Tim Scott. Calls for more censorship and greater restrictions of free speech are coming on a virtually daily basis now. Yesterday, the nation's most steadfast, principled and nonpartisan free speech group – the thing that the ACLU used to be – now the Foundation for Individual Rights and Freedom, known as FIRE, issued a scathing criticism of Governor DeSantis after he ordered the University of South Florida to immediately ban a pro-Palestinian student group by claiming that they are providing material support to Hamas. FIRE, which has gained significant support over the years from the American right due to repeatedly defending the speech rights of conservatives on college campuses, lambasted DeSantis's order as blatantly unconstitutional and a violation of the First Amendment, which it is, and urged the university president not to comply. Meanwhile, Nikki Haley today – last seen threatening Iran with a U.S. attack and pronouncing that this is not only Israel's war, but somehow our war – vowed that as our first acting president, she will impose new censorship powers against what she called antisemitism on campus, meaning any questioning of Israeli orthodoxies involving Zionism that will no longer be allowed in the United States. Meanwhile, Tim Scott, today, vowed to immediately deport anyone in the U.S. on a visa whose pro-Palestinian views go too far. We'll speak with the conservative journalist and commentator Brad Palumbo about the sensitive calls from Republican candidates and what it says about the state of free speech in the U.S. and parts of the American right. Then, after the killing of George Floyd and the spate of character attacks and firings it quickly fostered in 2020, the investigative journalist Lee Fang was one of the first targets of such smears as he was widely vilified in the media as a racist. Lee's crime? He posted an interview with a black American in which that interviewee expressed criticisms of the BLM movement for caring only when black people are murdered by white cops, but not one of the murdered by other black people. That was it. That's what he did. And his career is almost destroyed because of it. Well, I'll talk to Lee tonight about how the current environment – in which numerous people have not only been vilified for their pro-Palestinian views, but also got put on blacklists and gotten fired – compares to that moment. Lee will also talk to me about an extraordinary series of interviews he conducted on Capitol Hill with passionately pro-Israel members of Congress in which they described how their religious views, particularly their dogmatic belief that Israel must be strong to foster the return of Jesus and a rapture-like event is a key reason for their legislative support in the United States Congress for Israel. We'll examine how significant such religious views are and the strong bipartisan support for Israel and what other factors of motivations are at play.
For now, welcome to a new episode of System Update, starting right now.