Glenn Greenwald
Politics • Writing • Culture
Congress, in Chaos, Can’t Even Get an Israel Bill Passed. Dems Strip Border Security from Ukraine-Israel Aid Package. New Evidence of Israeli Atrocities
Video Transcript
February 08, 2024
post photo preview

Watch the full episode here: 

placeholder
 

Podcast: Apple - Spotify 

Rumble App: Apple - Google


Good evening. It's Wednesday, February 7. 

Tonight: something extremely rare happened yesterday: the U.S. Congress considered a bill to send billions of dollars to Israel—$17 billion, to be exact—on top of the $4 billion it already gets and all the weapons the U.S. has sent there since October 7 but the Congress failed to get the votes necessary to approve this transfer of U.S. resources to Tel Aviv. 

As we reported last night, a bipartisan bill that was negotiated by Chuck Schumer and Mitch McConnell, whose real goal—its top goal—was to send $60 billion to Ukraine, another $14 billion to Israel, and then threw in some very mild border security spending to pretend to Americans that they were all so concerned about them, was pronounced dead on arrival by the GOP House leadership, in large part because Donald Trump viewed the border security package is woefully inadequate. After a huge uproar from the GOP base about that border bill, all almost entirely against it, many Republican senators who were eager to vote for that bill—even some who helped negotiate it—then announced they would vote no, including Mitch McConnell, leaving all of the provisions of this bill border security—aid to Ukraine and aid to Israel—without any path to approval. 

From that chaos, all the key players in Washington began showing their real priorities, forced, for once, to drop their masks. By the failure of this omnibus compromise bill, House speaker Mike Johnson—whose first priority upon becoming speaker, he said, was to pass a bill not to help Americans but rather to help “our good friend, Israel”—immediately introduced standalone legislation to simply send $17 billion to our good friend Israel. It did not even contain the budget cuts to offset this new spending that he promised would be the hallmark of his speakership. That's the bill that failed last night in the GOP House by a pretty decent margin. 

Meanwhile, what Democrats are most desperate to get, which, again, is not anything for the American people, it's $60 billion for Ukraine and $17 billion for Israel, became their only legislative goal. They stopped pretending to care at all about the American border and announced that they would have a standalone bill just for Ukraine and Israel, with some also funds for Gaza, some to fund the war in Yemen and some for more aggression in Asia. Chuck Schumer, the Democratic Senate majority leader, confidently predicted that he'd have enough votes, including Republican votes, to get that passed through the Senate, even though there is still ample opposition among the House Republicans to sending more money to Ukraine, either because they oppose that on principle, or because they want spending cuts to zero out the spending increase, or because they won't send money to Ukraine without money for the American border. 

In all of this, you see that many people in the power positions of Washington, in both parties, have very intense and steadfast priorities. They really believe in these priorities, the vast majority of which have absolutely nothing to do with the welfare of, or even the lives of, the American citizens they ostensibly represent. Few events like the ones over the last 48 hours in Congress more vividly demonstrate that. So, we're going to break that down and tell you exactly what happened and what it shows. 

Finally: new evidence has emerged of the true nature of the destruction of Gaza by Israel and the Israeli Defense Forces, by no means confined to military targets, instead overwhelmingly aimed at destroying civilian life and civilian infrastructure in a way that has barely been seen in modern warfare, at least since World War II. On top of that, it has been confirmed that the IDF was behind a truly gruesome Telegram channel that glorified the extreme torture and mutilation of Palestinian civilians. While IDF soldiers continue to post social media videos on TikTok and elsewhere, mocking and humiliating the Palestinians and the lives that they are destroying—it's incredibly sadistic; not like a well-disciplined army or even a moral one—the U.S. is paying for all of this, remember, providing the weapons for Gaza's destruction and the whole world knows it. And whatever you think about this war, the cost to American citizens has already been quite high. From financing Israel's war, from defending it diplomatically, from providing the weapons. And those costs are sure to grow even higher now. Maybe you want to support Israel and finance Israel's war anyway, but at the very least, you should know about these costs. 

For now, welcome to a new episode of System Update, starting right now. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
7
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Watch Tonight's Monologue

Due to a connection issue, our stream was cut short tonight.
You can find the entire episode below.

We apologize for this technical difficulty - thank you so much for your continued support.

00:43:24
Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted

For years, U.S. officials and their media allies accused Russia, China and Iran of tyranny for demanding censorship as a condition for Big Tech access. Now, the U.S. is doing the same to TikTok. Listen below.

Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted
WEEKLY WEIGH-IN: Another Week Another News Cycle

What’s happening in politics that you want to talk about? Are there any burning topics you think Glenn needs to cover? Any thoughts you’d like to share?

This post will be pinned to our profile for the remainder of this week, so comment below anytime with your questions, insights, future topic ideas/guest recommendations, etc. Let’s get a conversation going!

Glenn will respond to a few comments here—and may even address some on our next supporters-only After Show.

Thank you so much for your continued support through another week of SYSTEM UPDATE with Glenn Greenwald!

Let's have a great week everyone!

🏆Dog-of-the-Week:

Dog-of-the-Week goes to TOBY. Our well-groomed cohost kept Victor company as Glenn responded to the Locals community questions.

British musician Winston Marshall schools Pelosi on populism at Oxford, while arguing against “This House Believes Populism is a Threat to Democracy.” Marshall argued that "populism is the voice of the voiceless,” & “The real threat to democracy is from the elites.” Awesome smackdown!

placeholder
10 hours ago

https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/4646417-top-senators-believe-the-us-secretly-recovered-ufos/

Mother of all conspiracy theories is that we could be off of fossil fuels. For decades technologies that provide abundant FREE energy have been suppressed. Zero point energy aka anti-gravity technologies have been known and they come from ET civilizations. Petro-nazi's (big oil) has spent huge amount of efforts to keep the public confused about the truth.

post photo preview
As the Daily Wire Publicly Negotiated a Debate with Candace Owens, it Secretly Sought -- and Obtained -- a Gag Order Against Her
Due to a prior restraint order against Owens, the much-anticipated Israel debate with Ben Shapiro appears to be off.

On April 5, Candace Owens publicly invited her former Daily Wire colleague Ben Shapiro to a debate about "Israel and the current definition of antisemitism." It was Owens' criticisms of U.S. financing of Israel, and her criticisms of Israel's war in Gaza, that caused her departure from the Daily Wire two weeks earlier.

Both Shapiro and Daily Wire CEO Jeremy Boreing responded by saying they would like to arrange the debate requested by Owens. That night, Shapiro appeared to accept her offer, writing on X: "Sure, Candace. I texted you on February 29th offering this very thing." The Daily Wire co-founder added: "Let's do it on my show this Monday at 5pm at our studios in Nashville; 90 minutes, live-streamed."

After Owens objected to the format and timing, she and Boreing exchanged several tweets in which they appeared to be negotiating, and then agreeing to, the terms and format for the debate. Owens had suggested the debate be moderated by Joe Rogan or Lex Fridman. Shaprio said he wanted no moderator. They ultimately agreed to the terms, with Boreing offering a series of conditions, including a no-moderator debate, and with Owens publicly accepting

Two weeks later, many readers of both Shapiro and Owens noticed, and complained, that the debate had not yet happened. On April 24, Owens addressed those inquiries by explaining that the Daily Wire had yet to propose dates, while reiterating her strong desire to ensure the debate happened.

But the debate was never going to happen. That is because the Daily Wire -- in secret and unbeknownst to its readers -- sought a gag order to be placed on Owens after she had called for a debate. They did this under the cover of secrecy, before a private arbitrator, at exactly the same time that they were claiming in public that they wanted this debate and were even negotiating the terms with her. To this date, the Daily Wire has not informed its readers, seeking to understand why the much-anticipated debate had not yet happened, that they had sought and obtained a gag order against Owens.

When seeking a gag order to be imposed on Owens, the Daily Wire accused her of violating the non-disparagement clause of her agreement with the company. To substantiate this accusation, the company specifically cited Owens' initial tweet requesting a debate with Shapiro as proof of this disparagement, along with concerns she voiced that Shapiro appeared to be violating the confidentiality agreement between them by publicly maligning Owens's views to explain her departure from the company. While the company claimed before the arbitrator that it did not object in principle to a "healthy debate," it urged the imposition of a gag order on Owens by claiming that the way she requested the debate constituted disparagement of Shapiro and the site.

To justify the gag order it wanted, the company also cited various criticisms of the Daily Wire and Shapiro on X that Owens had "liked." This proceeding took place as part of an exchange of legal threats between the parties after the public agreement to debate about Israel was solidified. Those threats arose from the fact that various Daily Wire executives and hosts, in both public and private, were castigating Owens as an anti-Semite. On March 22, Daily Wire host Andrew Klaven published a one-hour video that hurled multiple accusations, including anti-Semitism, at Owens. The Daily Wire cited Owens' response to that video -- her defense of herself from those multiple accusations -- as further proof that she needed to be gagged.

The initial tweet from Owens not only requested a debate, but also included a video from the popular comedian Andrew Schulz, who had mocked the Daily Wire for firing Owens over disagreements regarding Israel, and specifically mocked Shapiro for his willingness to debate only undergraduate students. The tweet underneath Owens's original debate request included a summary of Schulz's mockery of Shapiro which stated: Schulz now "realizes Ben Shapiro is only good at debating college liberals & can’t win debates against serious competition." 

After the prior restraint hearing sought by the Daily Wire and Shapiro, the arbitrator sided with them and against Owens. The arbitrator agreed with the Daily Wire that Owens' call to debate Shapiro, and her follow-up negotiations of the debate, constituted "disparagement" of the company and Shapiro. The company argued that any further attempt by Owens to debate, as well her suggesting that the debate would expose the Daily Wire's real "priorities," constituted criticisms of the site and of Shapiro, criticisms that the arbitrator concluded Owens was barred from expressing under her contract with the company.

The arbitrator thus imposed a gag order of prior restraint on Owens. Among other things, the order banned Owens from saying or doing anything in the future which could tarnish or harm the reputation of the Daily Wire and/or Ben Shapiro. Given that the Daily Wire had argued, and the arbitrator agreed, that Owens' offers to debate Shapiro about Israel and anti-semitism were themselves "disparaging," the Daily Wire has ensured that the debate with Owens that they publicly claimed to want could not, in fact, take place. Any such debate would be in conflict with the gag order they obtained on Owens from expressing any criticisms of the site or of Shapiro.

When asked for comment to be included this story, Owens replied: I "wish I could comment on this but I can’t." She added: "can neither confirm nor deny."

Boreing said: "your story is inaccurate to the point of being false," though he did not specify a single inaccuracy, nor did he deny that the Daily Wire had sought and obtained a gag order on Owens at the same time they were publicly posturing as wanting a debate with her. The confirmation we obtained of all these facts is indisputable. Boreing added: "I’m sure you can appreciate how fraught a high profile break-up like this is. For that reason, we are trying to resolve our issues with Candace privately."

It certainly seems true that the Daily Wire is attempting to achieve all of this "privately." Nonetheless, Ben Shapiro has constructed his very lucrative media brand and persona based on his supposed superiority in debating, a reputation cultivated largely as a result of numerous appearances at undergraduate schools around the country where he intrepidly engages with students who are often in their teens or early twenties. Both Shapiro and the Daily Wire have also predicated their collective media brand on an eagerness to engage in free and open debate with anyone, and to vehemently oppose any efforts to silence people, especially those in media, from expressing their political views.

It was the imperatives of this media branding that presumably led the Daily Wire and Shapiro to publicly agree to a debate with Owens over Israel and anti-semitism in the first place. Indeed, when it became apparent early after the start of Israel's war in Gaza that Owens had major differences with Shapiro, Boering responded to calls from Israel supporters for Owens to be fired by proclaiming in November: 

[E]ven if we could, we would not fire Candace because of another thing we have in common - a desire not to regulate the speech of our hosts, even when we disagree with them. Candace is paid to give her opinion, not mine or Ben’s. Unless those opinions run afoul of the law or she violates the terms of her contract in some way, her job is secure and she is welcome at Daily Wire.

But a mere four months later, Owens, despite being of one of the company's most popular hosts, was out. The company had concluded that her increasingly vocal criticisms of Israel, opposition to U.S. financing of it, and her views on anti-semitism were incompatible with the Daily Wire's policies.

All of those issues would likely have been the subject of the public debate that Owens sought, and that the Daily Wire claimed to want. Instead, the Daily Wire has succeeded in obtaining a gag order that, on its face, prevents Owens, in advance, from questioning or criticizing both the Daily Wire or Shapiro in any way.

 

 

Read full Article
post photo preview
THE WEEKLY UPDATE: MAY 6-10
Weekly Newsletter

We are pleased to send you a summary of the key stories we covered last week on SYSTEM UPDATE. 

—Glenn Greenwald

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
SYSTEM UPDATE RECAP: May 6-10
Weekly Recap

Welcome to the SYSTEM UPDATE recap, your weekend digest featuring everything we’ve covered throughout the previous week. 

Prefer to listen to your daily news analysis? Reminder that FULL episodes of SYSTEM UPDATE are available anywhere you listen to podcasts🎙️

Enjoy!


MONDAY, MAY 6 - EPISODE 267

Russia-Ukraine War Escalates Amid Nuclear Threats, Israel Was Motive Behind TikTok Ban; PLUS: Batya Ungar-Sargon on New Book 

Full transcript available for paid supporters: HERE

 

WATCH THE EPISODE

Intro (7:26)

Dangerous Escalation Threats (12:46)

Pro-Israel Repression (38:06)

Interview with Batya Ungar-Sargon (52:40)

Outro (1:39:02)

 

TUESDAY, MAY 7 - EPISODE 268

TikTok Constitutionally Challenges Forced Sale, Lawmakers Exploit Holocaust to Feed Moral Panic over Antisemitism; PLUS: The Ozempic Craze with author Johann Hari

Full transcript available for paid supporters: HERE

 

WATCH THE EPISODE

Intro (9:09)

TikTok Ban (15:29)

Antisemitism Moral Panic (41:30)

Interview with Johann Hari (55:55)

Outro (1:23:15)

 

Supporters-Only After Show for Tuesday, May 7

We moved to Locals for our supporters-only, interactive after show where Glenn shared his thoughts on some audience questions and comments:

 

First, Glenn reveals his thoughts on the 2024 Pulitzer Prize winners. 

 

@JJohnx

Johann Hari was infamously involved in a plagiarism/Wikipedia attack on colleagues a number of years back. Does Glenn believe that JH has moved on from this and paid the price. Because I first became aware of him at the time of this scandal, rightly or wrongly, I find it difficult to listen without alarm bells ringing as it were.

 

Available for paid supporters here

Want to join us every Tuesday and Thursday for this supporter-exclusive, live after show? Become a paid supporter here!

 

FRIDAY, MAY 10

Rumble Live: Defending Your Human Right to Freedom of Expression

Glenn Greenwald joins Rumble Live in Toronto to discuss the importance of defending the human right to freedom of expression as Canada prepares to enact the restrictive “Online Harms Act.” 


WATCH THE SPEECH

Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals