Glenn Greenwald
Politics • Writing • Culture
The Same Establishment Playbook is Used to Malign the Character of Leakers and Distract Attention From the Substance of the Revelations
System Update Episode #70 dives into the media's treatment of the Discord leaker
April 14, 2023
post photo preview
Daniel Ellsberg speaks to the press outside the Federal Building in Los Angeles, April 28, 1973. Credit: Wally Fong / Associated Press.

On a virtually daily basis, one can find authorized leaks in The New York Times, The Washington Post, on CNN and NBC News: meaning stories dressed up as leaks from anonymous sources that are, in fact, nothing more than messaging assertions that the CIA, FBI, Homeland Security and the Pentagon have instructed these subservient media corporations to disseminate. When that happens, the leaker is never found or punished: even when the leaks are designated as the most serious crimes under the U.S. criminal code, such as when The Washington Post's long-time CIA spokesman David Ignatius in early 2017 published the contents of the intercepted phone calls between Trump's incoming National Security Advisor Michael Flynn and Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak. Most of Russiagate was constructed based on authorized leaks, a generous way of describing official propaganda from the U.S. Security State laundered in the American corporate press.

But when it comes to unauthorized leaks -- which result in the disclosure of secret evidence showing that the U.S. Security State lied, acted corruptly, or broke laws -- that is when the full weight of establishment power comes crashing down on the head of the leaker. They are found and arrested. Their character is destroyed. And now -- in a new and genuinely shocking escalation -- it is the largest media corporations themselves, such as the Times and the Post, that actually do the FBI's work by hunting down the leaker, exposing him, and ensuring his arrest. 

This playback is always used in such cases and is easily recognized. The point is to shift attention from the substance of the embarrassing and incriminating disclosures onto the personal traits of the person who exposed them, so as to make the public forget about what they learned and come to see the leaker as so unlikeable that they want nothing to do with the disclosures themselves. Thus:

When Daniel Ellsberg leaked the Pentagon Papers – showing the US Government was lying to the American public that it believed it could win the war in Vietnam – FBI and CIA agents broke into the office of his psychoanalyst to try to expose his psychosexual secrets to discredit him and distract from the substance of the disclosures.

When Chelsea Manning leaked massive evidence of hidden US war crimes to WikiLeaks, long-time anti-LGBT bigot Joy Ann Reid of MSNBC and others said the overarching motive was mental illness over gender identity.

When it became clear that Julian Assange had created a powerful and formidible instrument for holding the U.S. Security State accountable and exposing their lies and crimes -- WikiLeaks -- corporate outlets began puking up a deluge of personal attacks against him, ones designed to make people conclude he is so repellent that the disclosures he enabled should be ignored because he was just too personally distasteful. The then-editor-in-chief of The New York Times Bill Keller even stooped to demeaning his personal hygiene, publishing this 2011 paragraph that he said he received from one of his reporters:

“He was alert but disheveled, like a bag lady walking in off the street, wearing a dingy, light-colored sport coat and cargo pants, dirty white shirt, beat-up sneakers and filthy white socks that collapsed around his ankles. He smelled as if he hadn’t bathed in days.”

When Edward Snowden furnished to myself and Laura Poitras the previously secret evidence that Obama national security official James Clapper lied to the public when denying that the NSA spied en masse on millions of Americans --  reporting that ended up winning every major journalism prize in the West and that caused an appellate court to rule that Obama's NSA had acted both unconstituitonally and illegally in infringing the privacy rights of millions of Americans -- CNN, NYT. NBC and The New Yorkier's Jeffrey Toobin labeled him a "narcissist" for believing he knew better than everyone else, and numerous outlets dug through his old blog comments to prove he had bad politics as a teenager.

Now, when doing the FBI's work by outing Jack Teixeira, both the Washington Post and CNN are emphasizing transgressive comments he made about race and anti-Semitism in a teenagers' gaming room to distract attention from the lies these docs reveal about, among other things, Biden's role in Ukraine.

On last night's episode of SYSTEM UPDATE, we examined the media's conduct this week with regard to the leaker, and the way in which they proudly did the FBI's job of hunting him down, exposing him and ensuring his arrest. On Monday night, we examined the key revelations from those documents and the strange circumstances surrounding that leak. The key leaked documents we examined can be read at the link below.

A full transcript for last night's episode will be posted later today on Locals (we post transcripts for each night's show on this platform exclusively for our Locals subscribers); the transcript for Monday night's show is below. And you can watch the full SYSTEM UPDATE episode on the video player below.

To support the independent journalism we are doing here and with our live nightly SYSTEM UPDATE program on Rumble, please join our Locals community; that gives you full access to our live interactive after-show on Tuesday and Thursday night, all of our written journalism, and full transcripts for each night's show:

 

community logo
Join the Glenn Greenwald Community
To read more articles like this, sign up and join my community today
14
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Colorado Gov. Jared Polis says Kamala Harris Would Combat "Rampant Antisemitism" on College Campuses

Colorado Governor Jared Polis tells Michael Tracey that Kamala Harris has been a staunch supporter of Israel and that she would rein in the "rampant antisemitism" he says exists on college campuses.

00:04:18
Michael Tracey Interviews Rep. Jason Crow (D-CO) in "Spin Room"

Rep. Jason Crow (D-CO) tells Michael Tracey that it makes sense for Kamala Harris to welcome Dick Cheney's endorsement because this election is about supporting someone who "respects the rule of law." He then avoids answering whether Dick Cheney respected the Constitution...

00:01:35
Michael Tracey interviews Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA)

Michael interviews Rep. Ted Lieu about Dick Cheney endorsing Kamala and whether he still believes Trump colluded with Russia:

00:03:00
Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted

For years, U.S. officials and their media allies accused Russia, China and Iran of tyranny for demanding censorship as a condition for Big Tech access. Now, the U.S. is doing the same to TikTok. Listen below.

Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted
4 hours ago

Doesn't anybody wonder what Biden is doing in Angola? I found this: Biolab Company Limited- Get in touch - pharmaceuticalbank.com

Biolab Company Limited is located in Mueang Samut Prakan District, Angola. 6.5K+ Wholesalers, Manufacturers, and Product distributors. Phone: +66 2 709 3124. ... Biolab Company Limited location. Country: Angola.

J.K. Rowling on X

The rewriting of history begins.

Opponents of gender ideology haven't merely 'endured unsparing criticism'. I haven't simply been told I 'betrayed real feminism' or received a few book-burning videos.

I've been sent thousands of threats of murder, rape and violence. A trans woman posted my family's home address with a bomb-making guide. My eldest child was targeted by a prominent trans activist who attempted to doxx her and ended up doxxing the wrong young woman. I could write a twenty thousand word essay on what the consequences have been to me and my family, and what we've endured is NOTHING compared to the harm done to others.

By standing up to a movement that relies on threats of violence, ostracisation and guilt-by-association, all of us have been smeared and defamed, but many have lost their livelihoods. Some have been physically assaulted by trans activists. Female politicians have been forced to hire personal security on the advice of police. The news that one...

Supreme white privilege is on display with Biden pardon of guilty son.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cgl92p0yjw7o

post photo preview
Will Trump's Second Term Promote Economic Populism? Matt Stoller On Cabinet Picks To Fight Corporate Power
System Update #372

Watch the Interview; Listen as a Podcast;


It should come as no surprise to anyone who has watched Donald Trump, especially during his first term, that his choices for cabinet secretaries and other key positions are a wild, haphazard, hodgepodge of ideologies, political factions and establishment popularity. To me, this is classic Trump, and how power ends up being dispersed in the Trump presidency remains to be seen. Still, while recognizing the limited value these choices have in revealing what is to come, they are far from meaningless, after all, Trump did choose them, and I think they foretell many likely policy conflicts on the horizon.

To help us understand many of these recent choices and what they represent for key domestic positions, as well as their impact on a wide range of issues, we will speak to Matt Stoller, of the Economic Liberties Project, in my view one of the nation's most informed experts on the attempt to use antitrust law to chop up monopolistic power and protect consumer choices against centralized, unaccountable corporate control.

Matt Stoller is so many things that it's very hard to list. I'm going to have to be very selective, otherwise, we're going to spend 45 minutes talking about who Matt is. To begin with he is with the Economic Liberty Institute and is also the author of BIG, on Substack, which, as its name suggests, focuses on antitrust violations and how particularly Big Tech, but other corporations as well, become so big that they're unmanageable. He's the author of what I consider to be certainly one of the definitive histories, if not the definitive history on the history of antitrust and democracy, and particularly how it focuses on Big Tech. The name of that book is “Goliath, The 100-Year War Between Monopoly Power and Democracy.” He's also a friend of the show and a friend of some of us here, including me. 


 

G. Greenwald: Matt, it is great to see you tonight. Thank you so much for taking the time to come on. We appreciate it. 

 

Matt Stoller: Hey, thanks for having me.

 

G. Greenwald: Absolutely. So, we have a lot to talk about, so why don't we just dive right in? A lot is going on, obviously, since Trump's victory and a lot of these appointments are generating some really interesting analysis and big question marks given how they're not exactly a model of cogency, which is what one would expect from Donald Trump. Before we get into all of that, though, there's a lot of debate, every time there's a new nominee chosen to head the department to be a cabinet secretary, there's all this digging and saying, what does this mean? Look, this person is this, that means the administration is going to be this or, this person is the opposite, that means the administration will be that. Giving is Donald Trump in general, but also how Washington works, how reliable of an indicator do you think these nominations are when it comes to the question of what Donald Trump sitting in the Oval Office is going to decide and what his administration will be?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Lee Fang On The Junk Food Industry Sabotaging RFK Jr.'s Plans, The Gaetz Situation, & More
System Update #371

Watch the Interview; Listen as a Podcast;


 

Lee Fang is my longtime colleague at The Intercept where he did some of the best investigative reporting and broke some of the best and most important stories, just using traditional shoe-leather reporting, falling money, tracing what these kinds of invisible but very powerful factions in Washington are doing in a way that few other people can or do. He's still doing exactly the same thing, but he's doing it at his outstanding Substack – www.leefang.com/ – which I think you do yourself a great favor to read.

 

G. Greenwald:  Good evening, Lee. Thank you for coming on. 

 

Lee Fang: Hey, great to see you, Glenn. 

 

G. Greenwald: Okay, good. You have been writing about Trump's appointees, not necessarily positively or negatively, but more about the reasons why so many of these power factions in Washington, corporate and political, have been opposing them – and more importantly, how. 

 

AD_4nXcMt2S8WCQOry-PwyHuYDcI9yrEy5orq5fnf5nkAaczdRHDjPxz6t9nWlag148Z7FLVaX-ooVA0rMb6Ihy0LcBQgTti4AjZY0QvnTlQSzkn5TlPxZHlYetBU1JBzCc8ncT1mtm0?key=JGBWLvlXknCTWKZj9-wZ8P_M

 

“Inside the Junk Food Lobby's Plans to Derail RFK's Agenda” is one of your new articles and it's interesting because there's not a lot of attention being paid to RFK yet – negative attention is spent on Matt Gaetz, Pete Hegseth, or Tulsi Gabbard – but it's definitely coming. That's for sure. It's just too big of an industry, billions and billions of dollars at stake, not to have it at some point become a focus. So, before we get to what they're doing to RFK, or what it is about his agenda that they dislike, tell us what is this junk food industry. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Scott Horton on Biden’s Escalation with Russia, US/NATO Role, & More on Ukraine-Russia War
System Update #371

Watch the Interview; Listen as a Podcast;


 

Glenn Greenwald: When I first started writing about politics and doing journalism, in 2005, one of the main focal points that almost everybody talked about was the toxic influence of neoconservatives. That was the first part of the George Bush-Dick Cheney administration and neocons like Douglas Feith and people who worked for Dick Cheney were extremely influential in the war in Iraq, the entire War on Terror as we came to know it. A lot of us thought that once George Bush and Dick Cheney were out of office, the discredited neocons would go away, and yet they never did. When Joe Biden was elected, people like Victoria Nuland were back in office, the neocons migrated to the Democratic Party, and now we have this increasingly dangerous war that is escalating as we speak, one that began in 2022, but that the United States played a great role in helping to provoke. As it turns out, the name of our next guest’s new book is “Provoked.”

A book cover with a flagDescription automatically generated



Scott Horton is, I think, one of the best, if not the single best critic of neoconservatism over the years, but also of American foreign policy and its endless war machine. His book is about the obsession that the United States, for whatever reasons, has had with Russia, starting a new Cold War, and especially the catastrophe in Ukraine. Scott is a good friend of the show and we are always happy to have him on. 

G. Greenwald: Scott, good evening. Thank you so much for taking the time to talk to us. 

 

Scott Horton: Happy to be here Glenn. Thank you very much. Of course, I've been a big fan of yours since back in 2005. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals