Glenn Greenwald
Politics • Culture • Writing
Congress Again Renews FBI’s Warrantless Spying Power Over Americans. Vivek’s Revealing Clash w/ CNN on 1/6. Natasha Bertrand’s CIA Servitude. Dems Pretend to Chide Israel [Part 1 of 2]
Video Transcript
December 15, 2023
post photo preview

Watch the full episode here: 

placeholder
 

Podcast: Apple - Spotify 

Rumble App: Apple - Google


Good evening. It's Thursday, December 14. 

Tonight: in Washington, the U.S. Security State pretty much always gets its way. This, yet again is exactly what happened over the last 24 hours as first, the United States Senate and then, the House voted on a bipartisan basis to renew and extend the FBI's power to spy on the communications of American citizens without warrants of any kind despite mountains of evidence that the FBI has been abusing that power and despite endless complaints and attacks on the FBI by congressional Republicans, many of whom voted to extend this power. Over the past two weeks, we had two lawmakers on our show, Senator Mike Lee, of Utah, and Congressman Thomas Massie, of Kentucky, both of whom held out real hope that this time Congress would do its duty and at least impose limits, safeguards and reforms on the FBI as a way of addressing all of the times they got caught abusing these powers. I told each of them that while I wanted to believe them, I was highly skeptical, given how many times I've seen exactly this happen over the years, namely that it seemed like there was an effort to try to limit the spying powers of the U.S. government, and yet always, in the end, they get enough votes to prevent any reforms. Unfortunately, my skepticism was validated. We'll show you what happened – how the FBI yet again won the right to hold on to this truly dangerous and authoritarian power – and, most of all, who in Washington is responsible for it.

Then, it is hardly a secret that the primary ideology of the corporate media is blind loyalty to the FBI, the NSA, the Pentagon, and the rest of the agencies composing what Dwight Eisenhower, on his way out the door called the military-industrial complex. Still, in a sewer of corporate media employees who perform this function, none is as corrupt about it, as mindlessly subservient to the CIA's talking points and agenda, as Natasha Bertrand of CNN – who proved her usefulness in this function by becoming the queen of the most deranged components of Russiagate – no CIA conspiracy theory was beneath her dignity to spread and then she became the first person in media to spread the CIA lie, before the 2020 election, that the Biden laptop was “Russian disinformation.” Bertrand has a new article on the Biden administration's alleged view of the war in Israel and it is really worth looking at just to see the kinds of rotted journalistic tactics that are not just acceptable but propel these people to ascend the corporate media ladder.

After that GOP presidential candidate, Vivek Ramaswamy appeared on a CNN town hall last night with one of the network's personalities, Abby Phillip, who went to CNN from being classified as a reporter with The Washington Post. Phillip asked Vivek about his statement that January 6 was “an inside job,” something he first said on the show when I was interviewing him and then something he repeated at the last Republican presidential debate. CNN's Abby Phillip sought to prove that this was a false conspiracy but rather than letting Vivek answer her question, she used the tactic that has become the most common among incompetent TV interviews – any time you see someone being heralded as a great interviewer on cable, it's almost always because they do this – she just simply refused to let him speak, constantly interrupting him every third word, talking over him in large part because she just had no idea what she was talking about, and in part because much of what Vivek was saying was demonstrably true but she really believed it was false because CNN never allows its host to tell its audience about it. And so, she's never heard it before. There's really a lot of illustrative meaning from this quite contentious exchange between Vivek and the CNN person so we want to break it down for you and show you the meaning we think can be extracted. 

And then, finally, Democrats are playing a deeply cynical, I would say, even jaded game when it comes to the posture of the Biden White House toward Israel's war in Gaza. From the start of the war, Joe Biden did what he has done his entire political career. He pledged complete, unlimited, unconditional financial and military support for Israel. He even flew to Israel to stand by the side of Benjamin Netanyahu as he promised that and he continued to do that to provide Israel with all the money and all the weapons they asked for. Even as the world began turning against the Israeli onslaught in Gaza and required the U.S. to isolate itself to continue to support Israel, he kept doing that as well. What changed, however, was that polls are now showing increasingly that the Democratic Party base is abandoning Biden. They're willing to not vote for him over his support for Israel's war. And ever since, Democrats have been making these theatrical gestures in public to pretend that they are chiding Israel and feigning concern about how they need to observe limits that they're not actually observing. And yet in reality, they're telling the Israelis the opposite, the things they're making repeatedly in public as well, that the U.S. financing and arming of Israel's war is not conditioned that any behavioral changes but instead is unconditional and eternal. No matter your views on this war, this sort of deceitful game-playing should repulse you on one of the most serious matters, this war in Gaza. The Biden administration is telling the Israelis one thing, doing that same thing, and yet trying to pretend in public that they're against the very actions that they continue to take, simply to deceive their voters into believing that they have now seen the light of day. And we're going to break that down and show you the evidence that demonstrates that they are, in fact, doing this. 

For now, welcome to a new episode of System Update, starting right now. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
10
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
Answering Your Questions About Tariffs

Many of you have been asking about the impact of Trump's tariffs, and Glenn addressed how we are covering the issue during our mail bag segment yesterday. As always, we are grateful for your thought-provoking questions! Thank you, and keep the questions coming!

00:11:10
In Case You Missed It: Glenn Breaks Down Trump's DOJ Speech on Fox News
00:04:52
In Case You Missed It: Glenn Discusses Mahmoud Khalil on Fox News
00:08:35
Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted

For years, U.S. officials and their media allies accused Russia, China and Iran of tyranny for demanding censorship as a condition for Big Tech access. Now, the U.S. is doing the same to TikTok. Listen below.

Listen to this Article: Reflecting New U.S. Control of TikTok's Censorship, Our Report Criticizing Zelensky Was Deleted
17 hours ago

I just gotta say, Glenn is really shining lately! I mean, he’s always good, but the last system update? WOW! I just saw Useful Idiots this morning. Aaron Maté had Briana Joy Gray as a cohost. (I LOVE both of them.) Aaron was skeptical of Epstein’s serious involvement with Musaad after referencing another Hero, Michael Tracy. Glenn’s show today put everything in the best, most appropriate perspective. Moreover, he ended with the principled difference between evidence and proof. Glenn did a fantastic job of saying: there’s no conclusive proof of Intelligence ties, but let’s not be naive enough to just drop it! And this after Tucker went out on a limb at Turning Point USA. I LOVE their 1-2 punch! Glenn, you’re not just principled, you are a friend with substance for Tucker.

14 hours ago

Presented with no comment.

post photo preview
post photo preview
Game of Thrones Actor Liam Cunningham on Gaza Activism and UK Censorship; Journalist Zaid Jilani on Mamdani, Epstein, the State of the Dems and More
System Update #484

The following is an abridged transcript from System Update’s most recent episode. You can watch the full episode on Rumble or listen to it in podcast form on Apple, Spotify, or any other major podcast provider.  

System Update is an independent show free to all viewers and listeners, but that wouldn’t be possible without our loyal supporters. To keep the show free for everyone, please consider joining our Locals, where we host our members-only aftershow, publish exclusive articles, release these transcripts, and so much more!

AD_4nXdqj3PgQpk8vYLh-ut4u7e6VaTgC8MjNdW-_qgEq1br3RI3zuTY6hiIxjyGR_qss2YBBiwl9ha80koSvut2g9APY6el5t3Cq7r6OuBdv1PpnKK8hzLYhAv8b23rgjdrylVJxsHcpYORJw7f2R_oErk?key=VlIHstP5tnI3rCSEFk6TqQ

There are times when we cannot cover everything that is going on that we think deserves attention, and one of the ways we try to rectify that is to bring on guests who we believe are highly informed, engaging and provocative. We have two guests tonight for you who are most certainly all of those things. 

The first is Liam Cunningham, who is the long-time working Irish actor likely best known for his central role as Davod Seaworth in the HBO hit series, Game of Thrones; but for our purposes he is also a very passionate political activist and analyst who has spent decades involved in political activism, in the last two years focused like many people, on the Israeli destruction of Gaza. 

Right after that, we’ll talk to the very independent, heterodox and cantankerous journalist – which I mean in the most flattering way – Zaid Jilani. He was my colleague for years at the Intercept until he left for all the right reasons. We're going to talk about a wide range of topics with him, including the fallout from the DOJ's announcement that it's closing the Epstein investigation with no further disclosures, the state of the race for New York City mayor, where Zohran Mamdani's primary win has sent a lot of people, especially the city's richest, into full meltdown mode. 

AD_4nXdqj3PgQpk8vYLh-ut4u7e6VaTgC8MjNdW-_qgEq1br3RI3zuTY6hiIxjyGR_qss2YBBiwl9ha80koSvut2g9APY6el5t3Cq7r6OuBdv1PpnKK8hzLYhAv8b23rgjdrylVJxsHcpYORJw7f2R_oErk?key=VlIHstP5tnI3rCSEFk6TqQ

The Interview: Liam Cunningham 

Liam Cunningham is an award-winning Irish actor, as I said, best known for his role in HBO's series Game of Thrones. Various outlets, including The Irish Times, have called him one of Ireland's greatest actors. He's been a political activist for decades, but recently he helped to organize and became a spokesperson for the "Freedom Flotilla,” in which Greta Thunberg and other colleagues were arrested and deported by the Israeli government for attempting to deliver aid to the people of Gaza when the IDF was blockading it. I've followed his work for some time, especially his political work and we are delighted to have him for his debut appearance. Hope it's not the last on the show. 

G. Greenwald: Liam, it's great to see you. I know it's so late in Dublin. I really appreciate your staying up to talk with us. 

Liam Cunningham: No, that's fine. It's way past my bedtime, but an absolute yes. For you, sir, anything. 

G. Greenwald: I appreciate that. All right. So, let's begin with what I just mentioned, which is the role that you played in kind of helping to organize and becoming a very well-known spokesperson for the boat that was intended to deliver humanitarian aid to Gaza as a way of circumventing the IDF's blockade of food, water, medicine and the like.

I think a lot of people didn't realize at the time what an actually dangerous and courageous mission it was. I remember in 2011, a very similar flotilla attempted essentially the same thing to deliver food to the people of Gaza when there was a blockade there and the IDF actually attacked that ship and killed 10 people on board. You had Nobel Prize winners, holocaust survivors and the IDF just didn't care. They violently attacked it. What was the impetus for your involvement in this particular action, even knowing how dangerous and provocative it might be?

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Trump Mocks Concerns About Epstein; Trump Continues Biden's Policy of Arming Ukraine; Trump and Lula Exchange Barbs Over Brazil
System Update #483

The following is an abridged transcript from System Update’s most recent episode. You can watch the full episode on Rumble or listen to it in podcast form on Apple, Spotify, or any other major podcast provider.  

System Update is an independent show free to all viewers and listeners, but that wouldn’t be possible without our loyal supporters. To keep the show free for everyone, please consider joining our Locals, where we host our members-only aftershow, publish exclusive articles, release these transcripts, and so much more!

AD_4nXdQ7dlWcVsr6gxA7vqLq-1A7mWjxjCfmkfW_idQ9AUuXFgbpYHaApRU0dHG1K-go6WP1EuQHkZ0TcaDhxBsLpBdDAN1Xt3U3Nh4bCNCrJAW6mSVm7ZY4a80mI9TZNNPvyHV75EmE75jxNEG2gV41zA?key=vLeq5wNRjH8OhqLXJDWEpg

 Much of the MAGA world was in turmoil, confusion and anger yesterday –understandably so – after the Trump DOJ announced it was closing the Epstein files and its investigation with no further disclosures of any kind. After all this happened, some attempt was made to try and pin the blame or isolate the blame for all of this on Attorney General Pam Bondi. Yet, Donald Trump himself, today, when asked about all of this, went much further than anyone else when meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the White House again: President Trump actually mocked and angrily dismissed any concerns over the Epstein matter and how it was handled. 

On our second segment, one of the uniting views of Trump supporters over the last four years has been opposition to the Biden administration's policy of arming, funding, and fueling Ukraine in its war against Russia. Yesterday, however, at the same meeting with Netanyahu, Trump announced that he would continue the Biden policy that he had spent so many years criticizing by now providing defensive arms at least to Ukraine, and he did so based on the longstanding neocon/liberal view that Putin is completely untrustworthy and therefore Russia must be thought because of Putin. That's what Trump himself said. 

Then, we’ll comment on Trump’s lengthy tweet attacking Brazil for its ongoing prosecution of former Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro, during the BRICS Summit being held in Rio de Janeiro. This was something we were going to cover last night and didn't have time to, but we will tonight. Brazil's President Lula da Silva quickly responded, very defiantly, by basically telling Trump to mind his own business. 

AD_4nXdQ7dlWcVsr6gxA7vqLq-1A7mWjxjCfmkfW_idQ9AUuXFgbpYHaApRU0dHG1K-go6WP1EuQHkZ0TcaDhxBsLpBdDAN1Xt3U3Nh4bCNCrJAW6mSVm7ZY4a80mI9TZNNPvyHV75EmE75jxNEG2gV41zA?key=vLeq5wNRjH8OhqLXJDWEpg

AD_4nXdFPqAU_UAlxnVl4bAGguNJXNdZxNBG5GYQRQ4rQ0s9nbGI3hy31ARaIkofh9-MnqDExEgQJwprJhlZCLFqt5TQ1AMEZL4dZuVcwfkWAUE9s8HKeccp7h8P74Smsa9IfJxGBCcOeBSZBRmO9vG3uQ?key=vLeq5wNRjH8OhqLXJDWEpg

Last night, we covered quite extensively the decision by the Trump Justice Department, not even six months into the administration, to completely shut down and close and stop all investigations into Jeffrey Epstein, as well as announcing that there will be no further disclosures of any documents of any kind, that whatever they've released so far, which has basically been nothing – not basically, has been nothing – is all you're going to get. 

This is a blatant betrayal of multiple promises made by key Trump officials over the last four years, before they were in the White House, but was also a complete 180 in terms of what key Trump influencers and pundits had been saying, including several pundits who are now running the FBI, such as Kash Patel and Dan Bongino, as well as the Justice Department, including Pam Bondi. 

We even showed you an interview that Alina Habba, the Trump attorney who is now the U.S. attorney for New Jersey, appointed by Donald Trump, did with Pierce Morgan while she was in the government, just in February, where she claimed they have a whole bunch of very incriminating lists with shocking names. She said there's video and there are all kinds of documents that are shocking, in her words, and she said they're going to be released over time because we've gone long enough where people who do these sorts of things, including are involved in the Epstein scandal, have no accountability. She said that is ending with the Trump administration. There's going to be accountability. 

Yesterday, the Trump Justice Department said, “No, there's nothing here. We looked. There's no such thing as a client list.” We know we've been promising and that JD Vance repeatedly said, “Where's the client list?” Donald Trump Jr. said, “Anyone hiding the client lists is a scumbag.” Dan Bongino, Kash Patel, Pam Bondi accused Biden officials of basically covering up predatory pedophilia by refusing to release the Jeffrey Epstein client list. Now, they're saying there's no client list, that thing we've been talking about and accusing Biden officials of hiding and promising to disclose, that doesn't exist. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
Trump DOJ: There's Nothing to the Epstein Story; State Dept: Syria's Al-Qaeda are No Longer "Terrorists"
System Update #482

The following is an abridged transcript from System Update’s most recent episode. You can watch the full episode on Rumble or listen to it in podcast form on Apple, Spotify, or any other major podcast provider.  

System Update is an independent show free to all viewers and listeners, but that wouldn’t be possible without our loyal supporters. To keep the show free for everyone, please consider joining our Locals, where we host our members-only aftershow, publish exclusive articles, release these transcripts, and so much more!

AD_4nXchraXAcM2XesxWhHUd_N92bq3HtZGBU0u87-_fbhgSvF_mW53lPXSclX3vc961GSDXkWZcNNf8FOPD8HtRT03BCNEDdQml65kDYVIePskT17DYTDjhr2qdoot9YMrl2ICIsDNxtoo3No9gS_87UbA?key=KgbZuF9MUUu9LACQfXBJhw

One of the most significant scandals among MAGA pundits and operatives within pro-Trump discourse generally over the last four years has been the one involving Jeffrey Epstein. 

Now, in less than five months, the DOJ announced today, the one under Pam Bondi, that they are closing the investigation, given the certainty that they say they have that Epstein had no client list. There's no such thing as an Epstein client list, he never tried to blackmail anyone and no powerful people were involved whatsoever with his sexual abuse of minors. They also say that he undoubtedly killed himself: there's no question about that. 

All of this is such a blatant betrayal of what was promised all of these years, such that all but the most blindly loyal Trump followers – like the real cult numbers, a lot of them almost certainly paid to be that – are reacting with understandable confusion and anger over what happened today and over the last several months. We'll delve into all of this and what this means. 

Then, Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced today that the group that al-Golani once led, long known as al-Qaeda's affiliate in Syria, is no longer officially a designated terrorist group. This is al-Qaeda. We'll explore what all of this shows about the utterly vacant and manipulated propaganda terms, terrorist and terrorism. 

As a note, we did not have enough time, so we’ll talk about President Trump’s tweet attacking Brazil and its government, on the day of the BRICS Summit in Rio de Janeiro, some other time soon.

AD_4nXchraXAcM2XesxWhHUd_N92bq3HtZGBU0u87-_fbhgSvF_mW53lPXSclX3vc961GSDXkWZcNNf8FOPD8HtRT03BCNEDdQml65kDYVIePskT17DYTDjhr2qdoot9YMrl2ICIsDNxtoo3No9gS_87UbA?key=KgbZuF9MUUu9LACQfXBJhw

AD_4nXf8opZ5QUDtAVaICU5qTM5Y1LjnKXrCQiFXaCgRyR0Wajit4anClkk9fzlucH9EsxtIoMf80nPijX1q2-P9anbJF2Br6tuTIhvUEcswwY_3YO8e6XnO1COADsy13uka9aFDYMs6gyeuA1ekGHkGHXo?key=KgbZuF9MUUu9LACQfXBJhw

Earlier today, the Justice Department issued a statement, essentially announcing that they no longer consider any of the questions surrounding what had long been the Epstein scandal to be worthwhile investigation; that essentially all of these questions have been answered, that there's really nothing to look into. 

You can read the Justice Department's statement here.

They're saying this client list that most Trump supporters, I would say, have been accusing the U.S. government, of hiding to protect all the powerful people on this list, now, that they're in power – people like Pam Bondi, Dan Bongino and Kash Patel, now they're in charge – they're saying, no, actually there is no client list at all. There's at least no incriminating client list, whatever that means. 

I don't know if there is a client list or not, but according to them, there's no incriminating client list. I don't know how you can have a client list that's not incriminating: to be a client of Jeffrey Epstein seems inherently incriminating. They seem to have said what the White House briefing said today when asked about this, because as we'll show you, Pam Bondi went on Fox News and was asked, “Are you going to release the client list?” And she said, “It's sitting on my desk for review.” 

Trump had strongly suggested he would order it released. Now they're saying, “You know what? There is no client list.” 

So, all these claims that Jeffrey Epstein had recordings of prominent individuals who he invited to his island, who had sex with minors, evidently, there's no incriminating material of any kind that would implicate any powerful person. Just not there, they checked. They checked the storage closets, they looked under the beds, just couldn't find anything. All the stuff they had been claiming was there for years, screaming and pounding the table on podcasts, making a lot of money over it, too, accusing Biden officials of hiding this all for corrupt ends, just not there. They looked, couldn't find it. 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals